A Cause for Celebration or a Call for Reflection?
Ahead of International Day of Education, observed annually on January 24, it provides a
moment to reflect on global educational progress and the persistent challenges that hinder
inclusive and equitable learning for all. This year, the focus is on the transformative power of
education in shaping sustainable and resilient societies. In the South African context, the
2024 national matric results offer a reason for both celebration and critical reflection.
With a national pass rate of 87.3% and nearly 47% of matriculants achieving bachelor
passes, South Africa has reached an impressive milestone—the highest since the advent of
democracy. These statistics underscore the resilience of learners, educators, and
policymakers in navigating a complex landscape marked by historical inequities, resource
disparities, and the lingering impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. While the pass rate
percentage is a key metric in evaluating matric results, it's also crucial to consider other
factors, such as the quality and quantity of passes. This provides a more comprehensive
view of improving learning outcomes. However, this progress coexists with ongoing concerns
that demand urgent attention.
The 30% Pass Mark Debate
One of the most contentious issues in South Africa’s education system remains the 30%
pass mark threshold. This standard undermines the quality of education and sets a low bar
for academic achievement, potentially leaving learners ill-prepared for tertiary education or
the workforce. Proponents, however, contend that the threshold provides a safety net for
learners facing systemic challenges, particularly in under-resourced schools.
The debate raises important questions about educational equity and the balance between
access and excellence. Quintile 1-3 schools, serving the most disadvantaged communities,
often lack the infrastructure, qualified teachers, and learning materials needed to compete
on an equal footing with better-resourced institutions. While the high national pass rate is
commendable, it risks obscuring these structural disparities that perpetuate inequality.
The PIRLS Report: A Stark Reminder
The Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS), published in 2023, revealed a
concerning statistic: 81% of South Africa's Grade 4 learners are unable to read for meaning
in any language. This highlights significant gaps in foundational literacy, which impede
learners' academic progress in later grades. Without solid reading skills, students face
challenges in understanding concepts across various subjects, leading to a chain reaction
that contributes to high dropout rates and limited success at the matric level.
School Dropout Rates: A Critical Alert
The recently published 2024 matric results have sparked conversations across South Africa,
with mixed reactions from educators, parents, and students alike. While the improved pass
rates and achievements in certain areas are a reason to celebrate, there is a deeper issue
that cannot be ignored—the rising school dropout rates. A substantial number of learners do
not complete their schooling, with an estimated 40%–50% of learners dropping out before
reaching Grade 12. Many learners exit the system between Grades 9 and 11, often without
attaining formal qualifications.
Over the years, South Africa has made strides in improving education, but the increasing
number of students leaving school before completing their matric remains a significant
concern. Factors such as poverty, lack of resources, and insufficient support structures
contribute to this issue. Despite the impressive pass rates, the dropout crisis threatens to
undermine the progress made in education.
Addressing dropout rates requires a multi-faceted approach that tackles both the symptoms
and root causes of the issue, with a focus on creating a more inclusive and supportive
education system.
Leveraging Progress: The Role of Leadership and Innovation
Addressing these challenges requires a commitment to transformative leadership and
innovative approaches to education. South Africa’s education system needs to move beyond
incremental improvements and embrace systemic change that prioritizes quality and
inclusivity. Programs like Leaders for Education (LfE) Leadership Development Programme
have demonstrated the potential of collaborative initiatives between public and private
sectors to build capacity for transformative leadership in schools.
The theme of this year’s International Day of Education resonates deeply with South Africa’s
socio-economic context. Education is not just a fundamental right but a catalyst for
sustainable development, social cohesion, and economic growth. Ensuring that learners
acquire critical skills and knowledge is essential for addressing pressing issues such as
unemployment, inequality, and climate change.
A Path to Action
As we celebrate the International Day of Education, let us honor the achievements of South
Africa’s learners while confronting the challenges that remain. The record-breaking pass rate
is a testament to the potential of our youth, but it is also a reminder that true success lies in
ensuring that every child, regardless of their circumstances, has access to quality education.
The journey toward an inclusive and equitable education system is far from over. By
prioritizing bold reforms and fostering a culture of excellence, South Africa can fulfill the
promise of education as a foundation for a sustainable society.
About the Author
Dorcas Dube-Londt serves as the National Marketing and Communications Manager at
Citizen Leader Lab and a Board Member of Casey Foundation Africa. With extensive
experience as a researcher and scholar, she is well-regarded for her dedication to social
justice, education, and leadership, having received numerous accolades and recognition
over the years. Dorcas is also a PhD candidate at the University of Johannesburg.
